February 3 lessons
I'm still putting on the final touches of two books, so I don't have time to do teachers' notes on a regular basis, but I did want to make a few suggestions about today's general news story.Justice needed
If you have advanced students, you might want to have them consider how convincing today's story is. Notice that it is from the opinion and analysis section, not the news section. Could it have been published in the news section? (Normally no because it is too opinionated. If it was in the news section it would have to be labelled as analysis).While there is a strong chance that the writer assertions of unfairness are correct, notice that it is difficult for the reader to make a judgment because she only presents one side of the story. There is nothing from the police or the prosecutors. That would have been useful to have ā although it is possible that they refused to speak to her. If that was the case, it could have gone into the story.
This is a good story for background, however, and it will be interesting to see what happens next. Again, the writer is likely to be correct in her assertions, but you can't be sure from the information presented. This is common with texts in the opinion and analysis section and it is why you can't rush to judgment.






